RAISE A1 vs MenteeBot V3: Specs, Price & ROS Support Compared (2024)
Zhiyuan Robotics vs Mentee Robotics — independent, side-by-side analysis.
빠른 평결
RAISE A1 leads in more DOF, higher payload, faster speed. Overall, RAISE A1 has an edge in 3 out of 3 compared categories.
RAISE A1
Zhiyuan Robotics
MenteeBot V3
Mentee Robotics
DNA 핑거프린트 오버레이
RAISE A1 MenteeBot V3
사양
$27,500가격No official price; a ~$35,000 consumer figure has been reported but never confirmed by the maker
175 cm키175 cm
53 kg무게70 kg
49자유도40
80 kg적재량25 kg
—런타임4h
1.94 m/s속도1.5 m/s
지원계단 이동지원
지원LiDAR미지원
200 TOPS컴퓨팅2x NVIDIA Jetson AGX Orin
Pros and cons at a glance
RAISE A1
Pros
- Shipping to customers (verified commercial availability)
- High rated payload (80 kg) for industrial pick-and-place
- Ships with LiDAR for robust depth sensing in low-light environments
- 49 degrees of freedom — full-body articulation
MenteeBot V3
Pros
- High rated payload (25 kg) for industrial pick-and-place
- 40 degrees of freedom — full-body articulation
Cons
- Still in development, no commercial availability
- Unit price not publicly disclosed (quote-on-request or enterprise-only)
- Closed software stack — no public SDK or ROS support
Frequently asked questions
How do RAISE A1 and MenteeBot V3 compare on price?
RAISE A1: $27,500. MenteeBot V3: No official price; a ~$35,000 consumer figure has been reported but never confirmed by the maker. Only one of the two has a public unit price; the other publishes a range or enterprise-only terms.
Which has higher payload: RAISE A1 or MenteeBot V3?
RAISE A1 rates a higher payload at 80 kg vs 25 kg. Payload ratings are vendor claims and do not always include a duty cycle — peak vs sustained payload can differ significantly.
Is RAISE A1 or MenteeBot V3 actually available to buy?
RAISE A1 is shipping to customers. MenteeBot V3 is in active development without commercial availability. Status reflects the vendor's published commercial position as of the last review and can change between announcement and actual delivery.
Which is better for ROS-based development: RAISE A1 or MenteeBot V3?
RAISE A1 has ros2; MenteeBot V3 has no ROS support. For research and multi-vendor robotics stacks, native ROS 2 is the strongest signal of ecosystem maturity.
Does RAISE A1 or MenteeBot V3 use LiDAR?
RAISE A1 ships with LiDAR for depth sensing; MenteeBot V3 does not. LiDAR adds cost and complexity but improves obstacle detection in low-light or low-contrast environments.
최종 업데이트: 2024