RAISE A1 vs NAO V6: Specs, Price & ROS Support Compared (2024)
Zhiyuan Robotics vs Aldebaran (Maxvision) — independent, side-by-side analysis.
クイック判定
RAISE A1 leads in more DOF, faster speed, while NAO V6 leads in lower price. Overall, RAISE A1 has an edge in 2 out of 3 compared categories.
RAISE A1
Zhiyuan Robotics
NAO V6
Aldebaran (Maxvision)
DNAフィンガープリント比較
RAISE A1 NAO V6
スペック
$27,500価格$16,990
175 cm身長58 cm
53 kg重量5.6 kg
49自由度25
80 kg搭載量—
—駆動時間1h
1.94 m/s速度0.5 m/s
対応階段昇降非対応
対応LiDAR非対応
200 TOPSコンピュータIntel Atom (upgraded in V6)
エコシステム開放度
—
RAISE A1
/100
70
NAO V6
NAOqi + Choregraphe. Massive academic community. Future uncertain post-bankruptcy.
Pros and cons at a glance
RAISE A1
Pros
- Shipping to customers (verified commercial availability)
- High rated payload (80 kg) for industrial pick-and-place
- Ships with LiDAR for robust depth sensing in low-light environments
- 49 degrees of freedom — full-body articulation
NAO V6
Pros
- Shipping to customers (verified commercial availability)
- Affordable at $16,990 — accessible to research labs and SMEs
Cons
- Short runtime (75 min) — frequent recharging or battery swaps
- Cannot navigate stairs — restricts deployment environments
Frequently asked questions
Which is cheaper: RAISE A1 or NAO V6?
NAO V6 is cheaper at $16,990 vs $27,500 for RAISE A1. Note that lower price does not imply lower total cost of ownership — see the TCO calculator on the Explore page for utilisation-adjusted figures.
Are both RAISE A1 and NAO V6 shipping to customers?
Yes. Both are commercially available as of the last review. Delivery timelines and customer geographies vary per vendor — check the manufacturer page for each.
Which is better for ROS-based development: RAISE A1 or NAO V6?
RAISE A1 has ros2; NAO V6 has ROS 1 only. For research and multi-vendor robotics stacks, native ROS 2 is the strongest signal of ecosystem maturity.
Does RAISE A1 or NAO V6 use LiDAR?
RAISE A1 ships with LiDAR for depth sensing; NAO V6 does not. LiDAR adds cost and complexity but improves obstacle detection in low-light or low-contrast environments.
最終更新: 2024